Dairy-Free Mexican Rice Pudding
How to make dairy-free Mexican rice pudding with coconut or oat milk, a condensed milk substitute, cinnamon, and a texture that holds without dairy.
Contents
Dairy-free Mexican rice pudding is arroz con leche made without cow's milk, using a plant milk such as coconut milk or oat milk and a sweetened substitute for condensed milk. The rice, cinnamon and sugar stay the same, while the dairy changes the body and the browning. This page explains the swaps, how the pot behaves, and how to serve it at a table where some guests avoid dairy.
Choosing the plant milk base
Coconut milk gives dairy-free Mexican rice pudding a rounded, faintly tropical body that sets firmly as it cools. Oat milk brings a softer, grain-like sweetness and a looser set, which suits a pudding you plan to serve warm. A mix of the two balances richness against a thinner spoonful. Choose the base for the texture you want, since the rice absorbs liquid the same way either way.
Replacing condensed milk
Condensed milk substitute for arroz con leche means sweetening the plant milk yourself and thickening it before the rice goes in. Stir sugar into warm coconut milk until it dissolves, then let the mixture reduce a little so it coats the rice. A spoon of starch or a longer simmer builds the body that dairy would have given. Taste before adding the rice, because plant milks vary in sweetness.
Cooking and setting the rice
Dairy-free Mexican rice pudding cooks on a low simmer, with the rice stirred so it does not catch on the pot bottom. The pudding thickens more as it cools, so pull it off the heat while it still looks slightly loose. Cinnamon goes in as a stick during cooking and as ground spice at the end for a fresher note. A vegan rice pudding made this way firms up in the fridge without separating.
Questions About Dairy-Free Arroz con Leche
Is Mexican rice pudding dairy-free?
Mexican rice pudding is not dairy-free as traditionally made, since arroz con leche simmers rice in cow's milk and often adds condensed milk. A dairy-free version replaces both with coconut milk, oat milk or another plant milk plus a sweetened thickener. The cinnamon and rice stay, so the character of the dish survives the swap.
Can I make arroz con leche with coconut milk?
Yes, arroz con leche works with coconut milk, which gives the pudding a fuller body and a light coconut note. Use full-fat coconut milk for a firm set and thin it with water if the pot becomes too dense. Stir often, because coconut milk can catch and scorch at the base of the pan.
What can I use instead of condensed milk in rice pudding?
A condensed milk substitute in rice pudding is warm plant milk stirred with sugar and reduced until slightly syrupy. Adding a little starch helps it thicken like the canned product. Make the substitute first, taste it, then add the rice so the sweetness is set before cooking begins.
Is this rice pudding vegan?
Vegan rice pudding follows the same method when you use plant milk and plant sugar, with no butter, cream or honey. Check that any thickener and flavoring you add are plant-based too. Served cold with ground cinnamon on top, the vegan version holds its shape well.