Cilantro vs Culantro: Differences in Taste, Health and Names

Learn how cilantro and culantro differ in taste, leaf shape, health properties and regional names, and see where coriander and Vietnamese herbs fit in.

9 min read1 views
— · 0 votes
Contents
  1. Cilantro and culantro at a glance
  2. How cilantro and culantro taste
  3. Health properties of the two leaves
  4. Coriander, cilantro and the English names
  5. Regional names: recao, cilantro macho and more
  6. Vietnamese cilantro and other lookalikes
  7. How to choose and use each herb
  8. Growing them for a taco table
  9. Cilantro and Culantro Questions
  10. Is culantro the same as cilantro?
  11. How does culantro taste compared with cilantro?
  12. Is cilantro vs culantro the same as coriander?
  13. What are cilantro macho and cilantro criollo?
  14. Does culantro have health benefits?
  15. Can Vietnamese cilantro replace culantro?

Cilantro and culantro are two different plants with a similar green, savory character. Cilantro is the soft-leaf herb of Coriandrum sativum, while culantro is the long sawtooth leaf of Eryngium foetidum. The names sound alike, but the leaves, the growing habit and the strength of flavor set them apart in the kitchen.

  • Cilantro leaves are soft and lobed, while culantro leaves are long, stiff and serrated.
  • Culantro carries a stronger, more pungent version of the cilantro aroma and holds up in cooked dishes.
  • The word coriander names the same plant as cilantro in many English-speaking places.
  • Culantro appears in Latin American and Caribbean cooking under names such as recao and cilantro macho.
  • Vietnamese coriander is a separate plant with a peppery, citrusy leaf, not a true cilantro.

Cilantro and culantro at a glance

Cilantro is the fresh leaf of Coriandrum sativum, an annual herb that grows quickly from seed. The plant produces soft, divided leaves on thin stems and a slender taproot. Gardeners know it as a cool-season herb that bolts to flower when heat arrives.

Culantro is the leaf of Eryngium foetidum, a perennial plant from the same family, Apiaceae. Its leaves grow in a flat rosette close to the ground and carry sharp teeth along the edge. The plant tolerates heat and moisture far better than cilantro does.

The two herbs share a family tree but not a growth habit. Cilantro gives you a bunch of tender stems to chop, while culantro gives you single long leaves to slice thin. A cook can treat them as relatives, but not as identical ingredients.

FeatureCilantroCulantro
Scientific nameCoriandrum sativumEryngium foetidum
Leaf shapeSoft, lobed, dividedLong, stiff, sawtooth edge
Aroma strengthFresh and moderatePungent and strong
Heat toleranceBolts in heatGrows in heat and humidity

How cilantro and culantro taste

Cilantro tastes bright, green and slightly citrusy, with a cooling finish that suits salsa and fresh garnishes. Some eaters detect a soapy note in cilantro, a reaction tied to how they perceive its aroma compounds. The leaf loses much of its punch when heated for long.

Culantro delivers a deeper, heavier version of that same green aroma, often described as cilantro with more force. A small amount of culantro leaf seasons a whole pot of soup or rice. The flavor survives cooking better than cilantro does, which makes it useful in stews.

Cooks who find cilantro mild may prefer culantro for its intensity. Cooks who want a light, fresh top note should stay with cilantro and add it at the end. Taste both raw side by side once, and the difference in strength becomes clear.

Health properties of the two leaves

Both herbs bring aroma rather than calories, and both are used in small amounts as seasoning. Cilantro and culantro leaves supply plant compounds and small amounts of vitamins and minerals. Neither herb works as a medicine on its own.

Culantro has a long history of use in herbal preparations in parts of Latin America and the Caribbean. Traditional use is not the same as proven treatment, and research on the leaf remains limited. Anyone taking medication or managing a health condition should ask a qualified professional before using an herb for health.

For everyday cooking, the health benefit of either herb comes from helping you eat more vegetables, beans and fresh salsas. Use them to flavor food you already cook, and treat any health claim with caution. A trained health specialist is the right person to advise on therapeutic use.

Coriander, cilantro and the English names

In English, coriander and cilantro can point to the same plant, Coriandrum sativum. Cilantro comes from Spanish and refers to the fresh leaf in American usage. Coriander often names the dried seed and the ground spice, and in British English it names the leaf as well.

Culantro is a different plant entirely, and English speakers call it sawtooth coriander or spiny coriander for its jagged leaf. The name culantro in Spanish-speaking regions can also refer to cilantro in some places, which adds to the confusion. Always check which plant a recipe or market stall means.

Vietnamese coriander is another separate plant, Persicaria odorata, with a pointed leaf and a peppery taste. It is not a cilantro substitute in the strict sense, though it can stand in for fresh herb freshness. The shared word coriander in English covers several plants, so the scientific name settles the question.

Regional names: recao, cilantro macho and more

Culantro travels under many regional names, and each name reflects local kitchen use. In Puerto Rico and parts of the Caribbean it is recao, a base herb for sofrito and rice dishes. In parts of Mexico and Central America it appears as cilantro macho, and similar names mark its stronger character.

The term cilantro criollo describes a local or native cilantro type in some markets, and it usually means the soft Coriandrum leaf rather than culantro. Cilantro ancho is a broader market name that can point to a large-leaf cilantro or to a dried form, depending on the vendor. Names shift by region, so ask the seller to show the leaf.

A shopper comparing cilantro ancho vs culantro should look at the leaf shape first and the aroma second. Long, stiff, serrated leaves signal culantro, while soft, lobed leaves signal cilantro. Regional labels help, but the plant in your hand is the reliable guide.

Vietnamese cilantro and other lookalikes

Vietnamese cilantro, also called Vietnamese coriander or rau ram, is not the same plant as either cilantro or culantro. Its leaf is narrow and pointed, with a dark mark across the middle on many plants. The taste is peppery and citrusy, closer to a fresh herb salad than to salsa.

Vietnamese cilantro grows well in warm, wet conditions and spreads readily in a garden. Cooks use it raw in rolls, noodle bowls and salads where a sharp, clean bite is wanted. It does not carry the soapy note some tasters find in cilantro.

A cook looking for a culantro substitute might try Vietnamese cilantro for freshness, but the flavor will not match. True culantro has the deep, heavy cilantro aroma that defines recao and similar seasonings. Choose the herb by the dish and the aroma you need, not by the similarity of the name.

How to choose and use each herb

Buy cilantro with bright green leaves and firm stems, and store it with the stems in water or wrapped in a damp cloth. Add chopped cilantro at the end of cooking so its fresh aroma stays in the dish. The tender stems carry plenty of flavor and can be chopped with the leaves.

Choose culantro leaves that are green, unbruised and free of brown edges. Slice the leaf very fine, because the tough texture and strong flavor need to spread through the dish. Culantro can go in early with soups, stews and marinades, and it also works raw in small amounts.

When a recipe calls for recao or cilantro macho, reach for culantro and use less than you would of cilantro. When it calls for fresh cilantro, the soft herb is the right choice. A cook who keeps both on hand can adjust the strength of the green flavor in one pot.

  • Use cilantro raw or at the end of cooking for a light, fresh note.
  • Use culantro early in soups and stews for a deep, cooked-in aroma.
  • Slice culantro finely because the leaf is stiff and strong.
  • Taste culantro in small amounts before adding more to a dish.
  • Check the leaf shape when a market label is unclear.

Growing them for a taco table

Cilantro grows best in cool weather and bolts to seed when the heat sets in. Sow it in succession so fresh leaves keep coming, and let some plants flower for the seed spice. A pot on a shaded patio can stretch the harvest through a warm spell.

Culantro suits warm, humid conditions and grows as a low rosette that can be cut leaf by leaf. The plant needs moisture and some shade in strong sun, and it spreads where conditions please it. In a cold climate, culantro grows in a pot that moves indoors for winter.

For a taco night, keep a pot of each herb near the kitchen door. Cilantro covers salsa, guacamole and fresh garnishes, while culantro covers beans, rice and braised fillings. Growing both gives the cook a choice of strength from the same small space.

Cilantro and Culantro Questions

Is culantro the same as cilantro?

No, culantro and cilantro are different plants. Cilantro is Coriandrum sativum with soft lobed leaves, and culantro is Eryngium foetidum with long sawtooth leaves. They belong to the same plant family and share a green aroma, but they are not interchangeable by name or by leaf.

How does culantro taste compared with cilantro?

Culantro tastes like a stronger, heavier version of cilantro, with the same green and savory notes. The culantro leaf holds its aroma through cooking, while cilantro fades with heat. A cook uses less culantro to get the same effect in a dish.

Is cilantro vs culantro the same as coriander?

Cilantro and coriander often name the same plant, Coriandrum sativum, depending on the English region and whether the leaf or seed is meant. Culantro is a separate plant that English speakers call sawtooth coriander. The scientific name tells you which plant a seller means.

What are cilantro macho and cilantro criollo?

Cilantro macho is a regional name for culantro in parts of Mexico and Central America, and it points to the strong sawtooth leaf. Cilantro criollo usually means a local cilantro type in a market and refers to the soft Coriandrum leaf. Check the leaf shape to confirm which herb you have.

Does culantro have health benefits?

Culantro leaves contain plant compounds and have a history of use in herbal preparations in parts of Latin America and the Caribbean. Research on the leaf is limited, and traditional use does not prove a medical effect. Ask a qualified health professional before using culantro for a health purpose.

Can Vietnamese cilantro replace culantro?

No, Vietnamese cilantro is a different plant with a peppery, citrusy leaf and does not carry the deep cilantro aroma of culantro. It adds freshness to salads and rolls, but a recao or cilantro macho dish needs true culantro. Use Vietnamese cilantro where its own flavor suits the recipe.

Read next

Latest articles