# Fish Tacos al Pastor

Learn what fish tacos al pastor are, how to marinate firm fish in achiote and chiles, grill it with pineapple, and how it differs from Baja tacos.

Fish tacos al pastor are grilled fish tacos seasoned with the chile and achiote marinade of al pastor. The fish takes the place of pork, and charred pineapple keeps the sweet, tangy balance of the original. The result is lighter than pork al pastor and faster to cook, with a smoky, citrusy edge. 

- Choose a firm white fish that holds together on a hot grill.
- Marinate fish briefly, since the citrus and vinegar in the paste start cooking the flesh.
- Grill pineapple beside the fish so its sugars char and sharpen the flavor.
- Baja fish tacos are fried in batter, while al pastor fish tacos are grilled.
- Serve the fish in warm corn tortillas with onion, cilantro, salsa and lime.
 

## What makes a fish taco al pastor 

A fish taco al pastor applies the classic al pastor seasoning to fish instead of pork. The fish is coated in a paste of dried chiles, achiote, citrus and spices. Cooks then grill or sear it and fold it into small corn tortillas. Pineapple, onion and cilantro finish the taco, just as they do with pork. 

Pork al pastor comes from central Mexico and grew out of shawarma brought by Lebanese immigrants. The meat is stacked on a vertical spit called a trompo and shaved as it roasts. Mexican cooks replaced lamb with pork, then seasoned it with chiles, achiote, garlic and pineapple. Flaky fish would fall apart on a trompo, so the fish version moves to the grill or skillet. 

Fish al pastor belongs to the wider family of seafood taco variations that borrow from meat recipes. Shrimp and octopus can take the same marinade with equally good results. Each version keeps the red color, the smoky chile depth and the sweet pineapple contrast. 

## The al pastor marinade adapted for fish 

The al pastor marinade for fish starts with dried guajillo and ancho chiles, toasted then soaked. Achiote paste, made from ground annatto seeds, gives the deep red color and an earthy taste. Garlic, oregano, cumin, a little clove and black pepper round out the spice base. Everything is blended smooth with pineapple juice, orange juice or vinegar into a thick paste. 

Fish needs a gentler marinade than pork, since its flesh is thin and delicate. Use less vinegar than a pork recipe, leaning on chile, achiote and a splash of juice. A spoon of oil in the paste helps it cling and keeps fish from sticking. 

Achiote stains boards, hands and cloth towels with a strong orange color. Wear gloves or work on a plate or tray that washes clean. Set aside a portion of marinade before it touches raw fish if you want a sauce. Marinade that has touched raw fish should be discarded or boiled before serving. 

## Which fish works for al pastor tacos 

Firm, meaty white fish suits al pastor tacos because it holds its shape over high heat. Mahi-mahi, red snapper, grouper and halibut all stay in large pieces on the grill. Swordfish and tuna steaks also work, though their texture is closer to meat. 

Delicate fish like sole, flounder or thin tilapia fillets tend to break apart in a marinade. Cod tastes good with this marinade but flakes easily on grill grates. A hot cast iron skillet or a grill basket keeps flaky fish in one piece. 

Fillet thickness matters as much as species when planning marinating and cooking time. Pieces of even thickness cook at the same rate and come off the heat together. Skinless fillets absorb more marinade, while skin-on fillets hold together better on the grill. Remove pin bones with tweezers before marinating, since small bones are hard to find later. 

## Marinating fish without turning it mushy 

Marinating fish for al pastor calls for a much shorter soak than pork shoulder. Acid from citrus juice or vinegar changes fish proteins, much like ceviche does. Left too long, the surface turns opaque, chalky and soft before it ever meets the grill. 

The right marinating time depends on fillet thickness, the acid in the paste and the temperature. Thin fillets need less time than thick steaks of swordfish or mahi-mahi. A low-acid paste of chile and achiote can sit longer than one heavy with juice. Check a piece, because firm, slightly opaque edges mean it is time to cook. 

Keep marinating fish covered in the refrigerator, never at room temperature on the counter. Pat excess paste off before grilling, since a thick coat burns before the fish cooks through. A thin, even layer of marinade gives color and char without a bitter crust. 

## Grilling fish and pineapple for tacos 

Grilling fish al pastor needs clean, oiled grates and a hot fire for quick searing. Lay the fish down and leave it alone until it releases from the grates. Turn each piece once with a wide, thin spatula to keep the pieces whole. The fish is done when the center turns opaque and flakes with a fork. 

Pineapple slices grill alongside the fish and pick up dark, caramelized grill marks. Cut the fruit into rounds or long spears so it does not slip through the grates. Brush the slices lightly with marinade or chile powder for a closer link to the trompo. Chop the charred pineapple into small dice once it cools enough to handle. 

A grill pan, cast iron skillet or oven broiler can replace an outdoor grill indoors. Each one gives good char if it is fully preheated before the fish goes on. Run a range hood or open a window, since chiles and achiote smoke at high heat. Keep a lid nearby for grill flare-ups and never use water on a grease fire. 

- Blend the chile, achiote and citrus paste
- Coat the fish and chill it briefly
- Preheat and oil the grill or skillet
- Sear the fish and turn it once
- Grill pineapple slices until charred
- Flake the fish and dice the pineapple
- Warm corn tortillas and assemble
 

## Baja fish tacos versus al pastor fish tacos 

A Baja fish taco and an al pastor fish taco differ mainly in how the fish is cooked. Baja-style fish is dipped in a light beer batter and deep-fried until crisp. Al pastor fish is marinated in red chile paste, then grilled or seared. The Baja version relies on crunch, while the al pastor version relies on smoke and spice. 

Toppings on each taco follow its cooking style and balance the main flavor. Baja tacos carry shredded cabbage, creamy white sauce, fresh tomato [pico de gallo](/articles/pico-de-gallo-menu-meaning-ingredients-preparation-material-45229/) and lime. Al pastor fish tacos carry diced pineapple, white onion, cilantro and a sharp green salsa. 

Some cooks blend the two styles by adding pineapple salsa or achiote to a fried Baja taco. Another route seasons the batter with achiote and chile powder for a red, crisp coating. Both hybrids keep the Baja crunch while borrowing the color and sweetness of al pastor. 
| Feature | Baja fish taco | Al pastor fish taco | 
| Cooking method | Battered and deep-fried | Marinated, then grilled or seared | 
| Seasoning | Mild batter, salt, lime | Chiles, achiote, citrus, spices | 
| Texture | Crisp shell, soft inside | Charred edges, tender flakes | 
| Toppings | Cabbage, crema, pico de gallo | Pineapple, onion, cilantro, salsa verde | 
| Fish | Mild white fish | Firm white fish or steaks |  

## Building and serving the tacos at the table 

Fish al pastor tacos start with small corn tortillas warmed on a comal, a flat griddle. Two stacked tortillas give extra strength when the fish is juicy. Spoon the fish onto the center, then add pineapple, onion and chopped cilantro. 

Salsas for fish al pastor should cut through the chile paste with acid or fresh heat. A tomatillo salsa verde, a chile de árbol salsa or avocado salsa all suit the fish. Lime wedges, sliced radishes and pickled red onion add crunch on the side. 

A taco night with fish al pastor works well when everything is laid out family style. Put the fish on a warm platter, with tortillas wrapped in a towel to stay soft. Set toppings in small bowls so each guest can build tacos to their own taste. Grilled corn, black beans or rice with lime round out the table. 

## Questions about fish tacos al pastor 

### What are fish tacos al pastor? 

Fish tacos al pastor are corn tortilla tacos of fish cooked in the al pastor style. The fish is coated in chile and achiote paste, then grilled alongside pineapple. The dish borrows the flavors of pork al pastor without the vertical spit. 

### Is it al pastor or el pastor? 

Al pastor is the correct name, meaning shepherd style in Spanish. The phrase refers to the spit-roasting method shepherds used for lamb. El pastor means simply the shepherd and is a mix-up of the dish name. 

### Can shrimp be cooked al pastor style? 

Yes, shrimp take the al pastor marinade well and cook quickly on skewers. Peeled shrimp need only a short marinade, since acid firms them fast. Grill them until pink and curled, then serve them with the same toppings. 

### What can I use instead of achiote paste? 

Paprika mixed with a little extra vinegar and oregano can stand in for achiote paste. The substitute gives red color but lacks the earthy, slightly floral taste of annatto. Ground annatto powder, if you can find it, makes a closer homemade substitute. 

### Are fish tacos al pastor spicy? 

Fish tacos al pastor are mildly warm rather than fiery, since guajillo and ancho chiles are gentle. The heat level depends on the chiles chosen and the salsa served on top. Add chipotle or chile de árbol to the paste for more heat. 

### Can I use frozen fish for al pastor tacos? 

Yes, frozen fish works for al pastor tacos once it is fully thawed and patted dry. Thaw it slowly in the refrigerator to keep the flesh cold and firm. Excess water dilutes the marinade and makes the fish steam instead of char.
